Casey Key Homes for Sale | Nokomis, FL

Casey Key is an exclusive and secluded barrier island just south of Osprey in Sarasota County, Florida, offering one of the most private and prestigious addresses on the Gulf Coast. With limited homes and strict development controls, Casey Key FL real estate features luxury waterfront estates and private beach properties that rarely come to market. The island provides direct Gulf of Mexico beach access, spectacular sunsets, and a quiet natural environment that attracts discerning buyers seeking privacy and natural beauty. Browse Casey Key FL homes for sale and explore one of Sarasota County's most exclusive real estate markets.

• Listings
• Dining
• Shopping
• Leisure

Highest Rated Dining

Pop's Sunset Grill

$$

1605 reviews

Seafood, New American, Tiki Bars

(941) 488-3177

112 Circuit Rd
Nokomis, FL 34275

Dockside Waterfront Grill

$$

1615 reviews

Seafood, American, Cocktail Bars

(941) 218-6418

509 N Tamiami Trl
Venice, FL 34285

Nokomo's Sunset Hut

$$

645 reviews

Seafood, Caribbean, American

(941) 488-1324

690 S Tamiami Trl
Nokomis, FL 34275

Crow's Nest Restaurant & Marina

$$$

763 reviews

Seafood, Steakhouses

(941) 484-9551

1968 Tarpon Center Dr
Venice, FL 34285

Giuseppe’s Ristorante & Pizzeria

$$

90 reviews

Pizza, Italian

(941) 837-2000

103 Triple Diamond Blvd
Unit 2

Deep Lagoon Seafood and Oyster House

$$$

385 reviews

Seafood, Soup, Sandwiches

(941) 770-3337

482 Blackburn Point Rd
Osprey, FL 34229

Max's Table

$$

517 reviews

Breakfast & Brunch, Greek, American

(941) 220-7463

115 S Tamiami Trl
Osprey, FL 34229

Rosebud's Steak & Seafood House

$$

333 reviews

Steakhouses, Seafood

(941) 918-8771

2215 S Tamiami Trl
Osprey, FL 34229

Waterfrontoo

$$

208 reviews

Steakhouses, Seafood, Venues & Event Spaces

(941) 918-4591

2205 Tamiami Trl N
Nokomis, FL 34275

500 Degrees Italian Eatery

$$

69 reviews

Italian

(941) 244-0203

3469 Precision Dr
North Venice, FL 34275

Casey Key Fish House

$$

693 reviews

Seafood, Bars, American

(941) 966-1901

801 Blackburn Point Rd
Osprey, FL 34229

Clever Monkey Craft Grill & Bar

$$

210 reviews

New American, Sports Bars, Salad

(941) 786-1834

1272 S Tamiami Trl
Osprey, FL 34229

La Botte

$

117 reviews

Italian

(941) 220-7038

535A US 41 Bypass N
Venice, FL 34285

Bella Rimini

$

60 reviews

Cocktail Bars, Pizza, Italian

(941) 220-3934

625 N Tamiami Trail
Ste D

83 Tavern

$

47 reviews

New American, Pizza, Chicken Wings

(941) 203-5312

8383 S Tamiami Trl
Sarasota, FL 34238

Ophelia's on the Bay

$$$

661 reviews

Seafood

(941) 349-2212

9105 Midnight Pass Rd
Sarasota, FL 34242

Cassariano Italian Eatery

$$$

547 reviews

Italian, Beer, Wine & Spirits

(941) 786-1000

313 W Venice Ave
Venice, FL 34285

The Breakfast Cottage

$$

414 reviews

Breakfast & Brunch, American, Sandwiches

(941) 313-9529

2301 N Tamiami Trl
Nokomis, FL 34275

Charleen's Cafeteria

$

25 reviews

Cuban

(941) 966-2400

582 Blackburn Point Rd
Osprey, FL 34229

Longet

$

36 reviews

French, Mediterranean

(941) 484-0377

133 W Venice Ave
Venice, FL 34285

Red Grouper Tavern

$$

133 reviews

Seafood, Burgers, Bars

(941) 483-3809

345 Commercial Ct
Venice, FL 34292

Evie's at Spanish Point Restaurant & Tiki

$$

283 reviews

Seafood, Spanish, Tiki Bars

(941) 218-6114

135 Bayview Dr
Osprey, FL 34229

Sharky's On the Pier

$$

1644 reviews

Seafood

(941) 488-1456

1600 Harbor Dr S
Venice, FL 34285

L'Olive

$

167 reviews

Mediterranean, Salad, Wraps

(941) 445-4904

1262 Jacaranda Blvd
Venice, FL 34292

Captain Eddie's Family Seafood Restaurant

$$

385 reviews

Seafood

(941) 484-4372

107 Colonia Ln E
Nokomis, FL 34275